Real Madrid's Controversial Penalty Triumph
In one of the most talked-about matches, Real Madrid advanced to the Champions League quarterfinals overshadowed by a contentious penalty shootout controversy involving Julian Alvarez.
Published March 14, 2025 - 00:03am

Image recovered from arabnews.com
The UEFA Champions League match between Real Madrid and Atletico Madrid ended with a dramatic penalty shootout that kept fans on the edge of their seats. Real Madrid ultimately defeated Atletico 4-2 on penalties, but the match was mired in controversy, primarily due to a specific incident involving Atletico's striker Julian Alvarez.
The intense derby at Atletico's Metropolitano Stadium ended in a draw with 2-2 on aggregate after extra time. Throughout the regulation time, Atletico had initially taken a lead with a quick goal in the opening minute, neutralizing Real Madrid's prior advantage from the first leg. However, Real missed a golden opportunity to equalize during regulation when Vinícius Júnior sent a penalty kick flying above the goal.
The controversy arose during the penalty shootout when Alvarez's penalty was disallowed. During the attempt, Alvarez slipped, and what appeared to be a slight contact with the ball using his standing foot resulted in the penalty being annulled. The VAR was instrumental in this decision, enforcing Rule 14.1, which mandates that any double touch during penalty execution leads to disqualification of the goal.
UEFA supported the referee's decision, citing that despite the minimal nature of the contact, the rules required the goal to be canceled. The incident led to a robust discussion on whether these rules should be re-evaluated, as the double touch was not intentional, sparking arguments about the rule's relevance in modern football.
Diego Simeone, Atletico's manager, expressed his frustration with the ruling, citing inconsistency in enforcement when similar situations in the past did not draw the same penalty. This sentiment resonated throughout the fanbase and among football analysts, demanding more clarity from UEFA on the protocol for VAR interventions.
This match has amplified debates over the use of technology in football, especially in high-stakes matches like those in the Champions League. The reliance on VAR to decide match outcomes continues to be a polarizing topic as calls for transparency and perhaps a review of existing rules grow louder.
With this victory, Real Madrid prepares to face Arsenal in the quarterfinals. Meanwhile, UEFA has committed to reviewing the rule in discussion with FIFA and IFAB, hoping to address the concerns raised by the football community and prevent similar controversies in the future.
The Real Madrid victory not only highlighted their strategic prowess on the field but also illustrated the continuing evolution of football regulations impacted by technology. The discussions ignited by this game might influence future amendments, showcasing how pivotal moments in matches can lead to broader changes in the sport.