New EU Commissioner Announcements Stir Controversy

Recent developments in the EU Commissioner appointments have led to significant political implications and debates regarding leadership and governance.

Published September 18, 2024 - 00:09am

4 minutes read
Belgium
Germany
Ireland
France
https://s.brsimg.com/static-000/cache/i/content/images/a/3/a/a3a5914b6fd96e64271af6a5fcc17f05-1200x800.jpg

Image recovered from boursorama.com

On Monday, the French government nominated Stéphane Séjourné, the former Minister for Europe and Foreign Affairs, as their candidate for the next European Commissioner. This follows the unexpected resignation of Thierry Breton, the outgoing French Commissioner for the Internal Market, citing personal reasons and a controversial good-bye letter to Ursula von der Leyen, President of the European Commission. Séjourné's previous roles include heading the Renew Europe group in the European Parliament, which positions him well in promoting an agenda of sovereignty.

Hours earlier, Breton announced his resignation via a letter in which he voiced discontent with von der Leyen's leadership. In his letter, he claimed that von der Leyen had requested France to withdraw his candidacy without prior consultation, leading him to question the governance in place. Despite framing his exit as immediate, this has not elicited specific comments from the EU spokesperson, who emphasized confidentiality in the discussions between von der Leyen and member states regarding the new commission's composition.

From an Irish perspective, former Finance Minister Michael McGrath is anticipated to take up the role of EU Commissioner for Justice. Ursula von der Leyen is set to confirm this during her announcement of the full portfolio allocations. The Justice Commissioner is entrusted with overseeing rule-of-law breaches and enforcing critical legislation like the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). This role will see McGrath replace Didier Reynders of Belgium. The Irish government initially aimed for a finance-related position but encountered hurdles, including von der Leyen's request for each country to propose a male and female candidate to ensure gender balance.

Meanwhile, Ursula von der Leyen proceeded to announce her cabinet selections, introducing a roster of 26 commissioners that reflect a commitment to gender balance. With 11 women and 16 men, her team includes key female appointments such as Teresa Ribero of Spain leading the green transition endeavors. This came shortly after Séjourné took the Deputy President and Industry Commissioner roles, following Thierry Breton's departure. Raffaele Fitto, an Italian politician from the right-wing Brothers of Italy, was also appointed Vice-President of the EU Commission, a move viewed critically by some factions in the European Parliament.

Fitto's appointment is seen as a pivot towards more right-leaning politics within the EU Commission, a point of concern for members of the Social Democrats, Greens, and Liberals factions who voiced their objections. Having previously served as Italy's Minister for European Affairs, Fitto's new responsibility will include administering the European Social Fund and regional development initiatives, aiming to better support the EU's poorer regions.

In addition to these highlighted appointments, von der Leyen's proposals include a variety of significant positions with new portfolios reflecting contemporary priorities. These entail boosting technological sovereignty, as announced for Finnish Vice-President Henna Virkkunen, and reinforcing commitments to innovation and startups through Bulgaria's Ekaterina Zaharieva. This strategic allocation seeks to align the EU's political machinery with next-generation challenges, such as digital transformation and regional inequalities.

As the new commission members undergo parliamentary hearings, their expertise and political stances will be subject to scrutiny, setting the stage for a politically charged confirmation process. This scrutiny is particularly anticipated for figures like Fitto, given his association with a Eurosceptic government. The process has also been marked by internal national debates and the balancing act of gender parity requested by von der Leyen, which have added complexity to the formation of the EU's executive arm.

Sources

How would you rate this article?

What to read next...